Free for dads · Baby's here

"I don't know what I'm doing": feeling helpless as a new dad

By Aidan Kyrke-Smith · July 2025

The first few months with a baby are full-on. Endless feeds, crying you can't explain, and a learning curve that feels like a cliff. Everything is new and almost nothing is certain.

Somewhere in the middle of it, a thought can creep in: I don't know what I'm doing. Am I cut out for this?

Why it knocks your confidence

In the rest of your life, you get to learn, practise and get better before it really counts. At work, at sport, in your hobbies. A new baby doesn't give you that. There's no manual that properly prepares you, no rehearsal, no routine that works every time.

So when the baby's crying and nothing you try helps, or it feels like you're guessing at every decision, it's easy to feel helpless. You can end up wondering if you're failing, even when you're giving it everything.

Feeling unsure doesn't mean you're failing. It means you're doing something completely new.

Nobody feels ready

This is the bit people don't say enough: nobody feels fully prepared. Every new parent feels lost at times. Every one of them second-guesses themselves and learns by trial and error.

It's not a flaw in you. It's what happens when you take on something as big as raising a person.

The aim isn't to stop feeling uncertain. It's to get through those moments without beating yourself up.

What helps

Trust the basics. You won't always know why your baby is crying. But feeding, changing, holding and comforting them all count, even when they don't fix it straight away. Doing those things again and again is how your baby learns they're safe with you.

Learn as you go. You don't need to know everything up front. Parenting is learned by doing it. Mistakes aren't proof you're doing it wrong. They're how you learn.

Say it out loud. Tell someone you trust: your partner, a mate, another dad, your GP. Just saying "I'm feeling a bit lost" takes some of the weight off pretending you're fine. And you might find there's more support around you than you realised.

Drop the imaginary standard. There's no perfect parent. There's just the one who cares enough to keep showing up and keep learning. That's the dad your baby needs, and it's the dad you already are.

Notice what you are doing. You're trying. You care. You keep turning up. Those aren't small things.

A quick check-in

Ask yourself:

If you can say yes to even one of those, you're doing better than you think.

If the helpless feeling doesn't lift, or it's turning into something darker, talk to your GP or call or text 1737. Dads get postnatal depression and anxiety too, and it's treatable.